Here are the 10 most popular restaurants in Lighthouse Point, Florida, known for their unique character, local history, and standout menus.
1. Cap’s Place Island Restaurant
Why it’s unique: This is the oldest commercial structure in Lighthouse Point and a national landmark. Originally established in 1928 as a speakeasy and gambling casino by Captain Eugene “Cap” Knight, it sits on an island accessible only by the restaurant’s private boat shuttle. The rustic, “Old Florida” atmosphere features cedar walls and historic memorabilia.
-
Popular Items: Fresh Hearts of Palm Salad (a signature dish), Stone Crab Claws, and local fresh catch like Snapper or Dolphin.
-
Location: 2765 NE 28th Ct (You take the boat from the dock here).
-
Customer Review: “The experience was like being transported back in time to a 1920s coastal Florida speakeasy… This is a unique dining experience and I will add it to my very short list of favorites.”
-
Links: Website
2. The Nauti Dawg Marina Cafe
Why it’s unique: A waterfront favorite located at the Lighthouse Point Marina. It is famously dog-friendly with a dedicated “K9 Menu” and hosts “Yappy Hour.” The vibe is quintessential casual boating life, perfect for watching yachts glide by.
-
Popular Items: Lobster Roll, Dolphin Reuben, and their “Hook ‘N Cook” service where they prepare your fresh catch. Brunch items like Lobster Benedict are also huge hits.
-
Location: 2841 Marina Cir
-
Customer Review: “Tucked away on the water, it has the perfect nautical charm and an unbeatable view… sitting dockside with a breeze and fans cooling you down is a plus!”
3. Papa’s Raw Bar
Why it’s unique: Owned by the same family behind the seafood market next door, this spot is all about “Eat, Drink, and Be Local.” It combines a fresh raw bar with an island-style tiki atmosphere. Unlike many raw bars, they also have a highly-rated sushi menu.
-
Popular Items: Fresh Sushi Rolls, Conch Fritters, Tacos (Steak or Fish), and Oysters.
-
Location: 4610 N Federal Hwy
-
Customer Review: “My visit to Papa’s Raw Bar was nothing short of amazing. The food was absolutely superb—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared.”
4. Fish Shack
Why it’s unique: A small, unassuming spot in a strip mall that locals swear by for the freshest fish in town. It is consistently praised for its cleanliness and high-quality seafood at fair prices.
-
Popular Items: Clam Chowder (often called the best around), Fried Snapper, Hogfish, and homemade Key Lime Pie.
-
Location: 2460 N Federal Hwy
-
Customer Review: “This is the best restaurant for fresh seafood… Mikey has to be the nicest and most sincere chef I’ve ever had the pleasure of being served by.”
-
Links: Website
5. Le Bistro
Why it’s unique: A hidden gem for fine dining. Chef Andy Trousdale is Michelin-trained, bringing upscale French and Continental cuisine to a cozy, intimate setting. It’s perfect for romantic dinners or special occasions.
-
Popular Items: Beef Wellington (a standout specialty), Duck Rillette, and their Wine Dinners.
-
Location: 4626 N Federal Hwy
-
Customer Review: “Amazing place. Michelin style food at a great price. Relaxed, cozy, unpretentious and very high-end food.”
-
Links: Website
6. Pampa Gaucho Brazilian Steakhouse
Why it’s unique: An authentic Churrascaria (steakhouse) offering the traditional Rodizio experience where Gauchos carve meats tableside. It is family-owned and known for warm Brazilian hospitality.
-
Popular Items: Picanha (signature beef cut), Lamb Chops, and the extensive Salad Bar.
-
Location: 4490 N Federal Hwy
-
Customer Review: “Great food, amazing service but you definitely need to make reservations because is always packed.”
-
Links: Website
7. Rocca Trattoria
Why it’s unique: A warm, family-operated Italian trattoria that feels like a home kitchen. They are known for generous portions and starting meals with a complimentary soup of the day, a touch guests love.
-
Popular Items: Linguine with White Clam Sauce, Veal Parmigiana, and homemade Tiramisu.
-
Location: 2014 E Sample Rd
-
Customer Review: “Definitely going back. Good food. Good service… Everything we tried was satisfying! Def would go back as this place is a gem!”
-
Links: Website
8. Sicilian Oven
Why it’s unique: While it has grown into a small local chain, the Lighthouse Point location (the original) remains a community staple. It focuses on wood-fired cuisine and “preparing to share” plates.
-
Popular Items: “The Boss” Pizza (fresh mozz, basil, tomato sauce), “Queen of Sicily” Pizza, and Wood-Fired Wings.
-
Location: 2486 N Federal Hwy
-
Customer Review: “My lunch meal was a Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken… The salad was fresh, no limp leaves and the croutons were toast on the premises… My complements to the management of this location.”
-
Links: Website
9. Bonefish Mac’s Sports Grille
Why it’s unique: A lively sports bar with a heavy emphasis on seafood and a fun, tropical island decor. It’s a go-to spot for watching games while enjoying more than just typical bar food.
-
Popular Items: Bang Bang Shrimp, Lobster Mac & Cheese, and Ahi Tuna Burger.
-
Location: 2002 E Sample Rd
-
Customer Review: “Great place, food is amazing with big portions. One of the best sports bars and restaurants that you will find.”
-
Links: Website
10. Lighthouse Thai Sushi
Why it’s unique: A fusion spot that excels at both Thai classics and Japanese sushi. Despite a modest exterior, the interior is cozy and the food is consistently rated as fresh and authentic.
-
Popular Items: Lighthouse Poke Bowl, Tom Kha Soup, and the “Lighthouse Roll”.
-
Location: 2476 N Federal Hwy
-
Customer Review: “Hidden Gem with Delicious Asian Cuisine! The calamari appetizer was very fresh… The sushi was fresh and delicious. We recommend this restaurant and will definitely return!”
-
Links: Website
